← all letters
023 · may 31, 2025 · 14 min

the truth is...your need for approval is killing your creativity

creativity dies when you're too busy pleasing others—my 21-day reset

_ _

Quick reminder, my YOUnique Branding slots for Q3 are filling up and I’m left with only two more potential slots to work with anyone looking to grow their brand in July.

Secure your spot on the waitlist here, and I’ll reach out within 3 days to chat with you about your project and what it needs to level up.

With that housekeeping out of the way, let’s dive into today’s letter…

_ _

I remember when I first started creating content.

Man, I was so excited. Those early days.

I wanted to share all my ideas about branding, personal development, and, you know, finding your real voice in business.

But something interesting happened. (Yeah, it always does).

My Instagram marketing posts?

They were getting all the love. Comments, shares, saves.

The metrics were screaming at me: “Talk more about Instagram marketing!” And you know what? I listened.

I totally bent the knee to the algorithm gods.

For months, that’s who I was. The Instagram marketing guy.

I made so many carousels. All about growth hacks, engagement strategies, the latest platform updates. And on paper? The metrics looked great. My audience was growing. People were tagging their friends.

But something felt… off. Deep down.

Every time I sat down to create, I just felt this heaviness.

That old excitement? Gone.

Replaced with this feeling of obligation. I wasn’t building the brand I actually wanted to build.

Nope.

I was building the brand my audience metrics told me would be successful.

And the worst part? Whenever I tried posting about the stuff I genuinely cared about—authentic branding, finding your voice, the psychology behind real connection—those posts would just flop.

Hard.

And every time that happened, every “failure,” it made me question if my own ideas were even worth sharing.

It messes with your head in a way no one warns you about.

There’s this Creator Burnout Study.

It says 71% of content creators feel trapped.

They’re making content they’re not passionate about, just because it performs well.

We’re in this epidemic of creator inauthenticity. And you can see the symptoms everywhere: burnout, inconsistency, and work that just doesn’t have a unique point of view.

It all looks the same.

It took me longer than I like to admit. But I finally realized something.

Something really crucial: The audience you build by trying to please everyone?

That isn’t actually your audience.

They’re following you for what you do, not for who you are.

And believe me, that’s a shaky foundation for any creator.

But here’s the good news.

You can break this cycle.

And you can do it in just 21 days.

No magic formula here. It’s about a systematic approach.

Developing the one thing no algorithm can ever take from you: unshakeable creative confidence.

What you’re about to read?

This is the exact framework I used.

How I went from an algorithm-pleaser to a creator with real conviction.

The kind of creator who attracts the right audience, instead of just chasing the wrong one.

The Audience Paradox: Why Chasing Validation Kills Your Best Work

So, here’s the trap. Most creators fall right into it.

They create something.

They put it out into the world.

They see what gets engagement.

And then? They make more of that thing.

It seems logical, right? Give the people what they want!

But there’s a big problem with that.

Your audience? They only know what they want based on what they’ve already seen. They can’t tell you what innovative, unique content to make next. Because they can’t imagine what doesn’t exist yet. How could they?

Think about it.

If Steve Jobs had just asked people what they wanted, they would’ve said “a better MP3 player.” Not the iPhone. No way.

And if Brené Brown had only talked about topics that did well at first, we might never have gotten her amazing work on vulnerability.

I talked to this creator recently.

She spent two years making educational finance content because that’s what her audience liked. The metrics looked great.

But she was miserable. “I dreaded making content every single day,” she told me.

Then one day, she just decided to post about what she actually cared about.

The psychology of money. Emotional spending.

Her first few posts on this new stuff?

They underperformed.

Big time.

But she kept going. And six months later?

She’d built a completely new audience.

An audience that connected with her authentic interest, not just her ability to explain finance stuff.

Her business is more successful than ever now. And more importantly? She’s creating content she genuinely loves.

That’s huge.

I call this “Creator-First Content.” And it pretty much flips the typical creator formula on its head:

  • Traditional way: Create > See how the audience reacts > Change content to get more likes > Repeat.

  • Creator-First way: Figure out your vision > Create content that fits that vision > Build an audience around your vision > Make your execution better (not your vision) based on feedback.

It’s a small shift.

But it changes everything.

Instead of letting your audience tell you what to create, you decide what to create. Then you find the audience who connects with that.

When I finally stopped chasing those Instagram marketing metrics? When I started creating content about authentic branding and finding your voice? Something interesting happened.

My overall engagement? It dropped at first. Yeah, a little scary.

But the engagement I did get? It was deeper.

Comments went from “Great tips!” to “This is exactly what I’ve been struggling with.”

My DMs changed too. From people asking for quick fixes, to people sharing how my content had totally shifted their approach to building their business.

If you want to learn how to do this for yourself, check out my guidebook here.

But that audience I built by trying to please everyone?

They weren’t really my audience at all.

They were just passing through. My real audience?

They were waiting.

Waiting for me to have the confidence to create what only I could create.

And here’s the biggest “aha!” moment of all.

Audience-led creation? It’s actually backward.

Your most loyal fans, the ones who really stick around? They don’t follow you because you give them exactly what they ask for.

They follow you because you show them possibilities they couldn’t have imagined on their own.

They follow you for your unique perspective. And that’s something you can only develop when you’re not constantly chasing validation.

Unshakeable creative confidence.

It isn’t just some nice-to-have trait for creators.

It’s the answer.

The solution to that exhausting cycle of making content that does well but leaves you feeling empty.

It’s the antidote to the comparison trap and all that algorithm anxiety.

And the best part? You can systematically build it for yourself. In just 21 days.

The 21-Day Confidence Blueprint: From Validation-Seeker to Visionary Creator

“The reward for conformity is that everyone likes you except yourself.” That’s a quote from Rita Mae Brown.

And man, it hits differently when you’re a creator, doesn’t it?

The path to unshakeable creative confidence?

It’s not about totally ignoring your audience. It’s about resetting that relationship. So you lead with your vision.

And they follow because they choose to, not because you’re just giving them what you think they want.

These next 21 days?

They’re going to transform how you create. Who you create for. And most importantly, how you feel about what you create.

Each step builds on the last one.

It’s a system.

Not just to temporarily boost your confidence, but to fundamentally change your relationship with your own creative process.

For good.

Step 1: The 48-Hour Detox (Days 1-2)

Most creators don’t even realize how deep audience expectations have dug into their creative process.

This 48-hour detox?

It’ll show you exactly where you’re creating for validation, and where you’re creating from true expression.

So, start by completely disconnecting from your content metrics.

For 48 hours. No checking likes, comments, shares, or analytics. I know, it’s not easy. But it’s so necessary to break that dopamine feedback loop.

The one that’s keeping you hooked on validation.

During these two days, I want you to do the “Origin vs. Obligation” exercise.

Make two lists.

  • List one: Content ideas that genuinely excite you. Like, you can’t wait to make them. (Doesn’t matter how they might perform).

  • List two: Content ideas you feel obligated to create. The stuff you make because it performs well. Be brutally honest here. No one else is gonna see these lists. It’s just for you.

Now, look at where they overlap. Where does your genuine interest line up with what performs well? And where is there a total disconnect?

This exercise often shows creators they’re spending like 80% of their time making content they feel kinda “meh” about, just because it gets engagement.

Crazy, right?

By the end of these 48 hours, you should have some real clarity.

You’ll see where you’ve been compromising your vision for validation. And that awareness? That’s the essential first step to building creative confidence.

You gotta see the problem before you can fix it.

Step 2: Establish Your Creator North Star (Days 3-5)

Okay, so now you get where you’ve been led by validation instead of your own vision. Now it’s time to establish your Creator North Star.

These are the guiding principles. They’ll inform all your creative decisions from here on out.

Your Creator North Star?

It’s not about specific content topics. It’s about figuring out the underlying values and perspectives that make your voice unique.

This becomes your creative filter.

If a content idea lines up with your North Star, you go for it. If not, you let it go. Doesn’t matter how well it might perform.

Seriously.

Start by answering these questions. Really think about them:

  • If metrics didn’t exist, what would you create? Just for the joy of it.

  • What message or perspective do you feel is missing in your industry? What needs to be said?

  • What are you willing to be polarizing about? What do you believe in, even if not everyone agrees?

  • What topics make you lose track of time when you’re creating content about them? What lights you up?

  • What kind of impact do you want your content to have on someone’s life? How do you want to make them feel or think?

Use these answers to craft your Creator Manifesto.

It can be just one page. Or one paragraph if you're lazy like me.

This document should lay out your unique perspective, the transformation you want to create for your audience, and the principles that will guide your creative decisions.

Your core beliefs.

This document becomes your compass. Especially when you feel that pull.

That temptation to create for validation instead of from your vision. You just look at your manifesto.

It’ll get you back on track.

Step 3: The 7-Day Lock-in (Days 6-12)

Alright, you’ve got your Creator North Star. Now it’s time to put it into action.

We’re going to do a concentrated creation period.

I call it the Lock-in.

For seven days straight, you’re going to create and publish content.

And this content? It has to be 100% aligned with your Creator North Star. With zero thought about how it might perform.

This isn’t about being controversial just for the sake of it (I hate people that do this because it's so obvious what you're trying to do bro).

It’s about being deliberately, unapologetically authentic.

The rules for the sprint are simple:

  • Create from your internal inspiration only. What feels right to you.

  • Publish daily. Doesn’t matter if you feel “ready” or if it’s “perfect.” Just get it out there.

  • Wait at least 24 hours before checking metrics on anything you publish. Give it space.

  • Document your creative process. How does it feel different from how you used to create? Take notes.

The purpose of this sprint?

It’s not necessarily to create your most successful content ever (though hey, that might happen). The real purpose is to build that muscle. The muscle of creating from conviction, not for validation.

I wrote about how I built my audience entirely while being half-ready here.

It’s a different feeling, and we need you to be flexing that muscle.

By day 12, you’ll notice something pretty powerful.

That feeling of liberation.

It comes from creating what you genuinely want to create, no matter how it performs.

This, my friend, is the beginning of real creative confidence.

You’ll feel it.

Step 4: Strategic Audience Detachment (Days 13-15)

Now for one of the most crucial skills any creator needs.

Learning how to take in audience feedback without letting it define you.

This is a big one.

Here’s a truth I learned the hard way. A really hard way.

“Don’t let the praise get to your head, and don’t let the hate get to your heart.”

I say this all the time.

It’s not just some cute saying.

It’s a fundamental principle for building unshakeable creative confidence. Because both extreme praise and harsh criticism?

They can be equally dangerous to your creative process if you don’t have the right framework for dealing with them.

Strategic audience detachment?

It means you already need to have some creative confidence in yourself. A baseline belief. You don’t need that external validation when you already believe in what you’re about.

See the difference?

So, during these three days, you’re going to set up your Feedback Filter system:

  • The 24-Hour Rule: Wait a full day before you look at any feedback on new content. This creates emotional distance. It stops you from reacting impulsively. (I permanently have notifications off for this reason alone)

  • The Pattern Recognition Exercise: Look at feedback across multiple pieces of content. You’re looking for patterns, not just reactions to one post. Consistent themes, not just one-off comments.

  • The Implementation Test: For any feedback you’re thinking about using, ask yourself: “Does this line up with my Creator North Star?” If it doesn’t, acknowledge the feedback (maybe say thanks), but don’t feel like you have to act on it. It’s okay.

  • The Source Verification: Give more weight to feedback from people who seem like your ideal audience. Less weight to casual observers or critics who aren’t really part of your target community. Not all feedback is created equal.

By putting this system in place, you’ll develop the ability to learn from your audience. But without being controlled by them.

That’s a critical distinction for any confident creator. It’s about partnership, not dictation.

Step 5: Rapid Resilience Building (Days 16-18)

Even with your Creator North Star and your Feedback Filter all set up, there will still be times when your content doesn’t do as well as you hoped.

Or when you get criticism that just stings.

It happens.

It’s part of the game.

Building resilience is essential for keeping your creative confidence up through these challenges.

So, for these three days, you’re going to deliberately practice building resilience:

  • The Content Post-Mortem: When content underperforms, look at it with curiosity, not judgment. What can you learn about how you executed it, while still staying true to your vision? Be an investigator, not a critic of yourself.

  • The Resilience Ritual: Develop a specific routine. Something you do when you’re dealing with disappointing results or harsh feedback. Maybe it’s journaling, talking to a trusted friend or mentor, or re-reading your Creator Manifesto. Find what works for you.

  • The Intentional Risk: Create and publish something that intentionally pushes you beyond your comfort zone. Just a little. This builds that emotional muscle. The one that lets you take creative risks, no matter the outcome. It’s like exercise for your confidence.

Remember, resilience isn’t about never feeling disappointed or hurt by how your content performs.

It’s about not letting those feelings dictate your creative decisions moving forward.

Feel it, learn from it, then get back to your vision.

Step 6: The You Launch (Days 19-21)

This is the final phase.

Developing unshakeable creative confidence means learning to amplify your unique voice once you’ve really found it.

It’s time to own it.

With your Creator North Star clear, your Vision Sprint done, your Feedback Filter in place, and your Resilience Ritual developed, you’re now ready.

Ready to strategically position yourself based on your authentic creative identity. The real you.

During these final three days:

  • Audit and Align Your Platform: Look at your bio, your profile, your content themes. Do they clearly scream your Creator North Star? Get rid of anything that dilutes your unique perspective. Make it clean. Make it you.

  • Craft Your Signature Framework: Develop a simple, memorable framework. Something that sums up your unique approach. This becomes a content anchor. Something you can come back to again and again. It makes your ideas sticky.

  • Identify Your Beacon Content: Plan 3-5 pieces of what I call “beacon content.” These are definitive works. They perfectly show off your Creator North Star. And they attract exactly the right people to your platform. Think of them as lighthouses for your ideal audience.

  • Create Your Confidence Maintenance Plan: This 21-day thing is great, but confidence needs ongoing care. Establish a regular practice for keeping your creative confidence strong after these 21 days are over. How will you keep checking in with your North Star?

The magic of this Magnetic Identity approach? It doesn’t require you to compromise your vision just to build an audience.

No way.

Instead, it positions your authentic vision in the most compelling way possible. And that naturally attracts the right people to your work. They’ll find you.

By the end of these 21 days, you won’t just have more confidence in your creative decisions.

You’ll have a complete system.

A system for maintaining that confidence, even when trends change, algorithms shift, and new platforms pop up. You’ll be anchored.

The creator economy doesn’t need more people creating what they think will perform well.

It needs more people creating with unshakeable confidence in their own distinctive vision.

Their true voice.

That’s how you build not just content that performs.

That’s how you build a legacy that actually matters.

That’s the stuff that lasts.

When you're ready, here's how I can help you:

  • The YOUnique Branding System for Q3 waitlist is open and if you're looking at launching a product or brand soon, I can help you cover all your blind spots before launch day

  • Grow Your Business with Content is a workbook and guidebook pack designed to help you understand everything you need to grow a business with content in 2025 on any platform

​Good read? Coffee donations appreciated :)​

I appreciate all the support!

See you on social

Love, Mike.

this letter lives on substack too. that's where the conversation happens.

comment on this letter ↗

or get the next one in your inbox:

free, every monday. substack opens to confirm, then you're in.

← № 022why authenticity fails without strategy (and the 5-step fix)024Q&A: do discounts help or hurt business